Should I or Should I not?
Raven's Brew Coffee, goals, happiness, inner peace, positive thinking, responsibility, thinking errors January 22nd, 2009The time has finally come. It’s been long in the making… and here it is….. the last of the thinking errors (see others in the list at the bottom of this post.) And what a great series it has been as I have learned so much from you my readers and I thank you for that. There are probably more thinking errors that you will notice as you go along this journey we call life, but most will fit into one of the categories we we have talked about here. If you notice others I would love for you to drop me a line and let me know. For now, let’s wrap up the last one on the list.
16. Should statements: using “shoulds”, “shouldn’ts”, “musts”, “oughts”, and “needs” to motivate yourself or others through guilt.
photo by: Axel Buhrmann
Consider this:
“I should go see my mom today, but I can’t because I need to go to the store. I really shouldn’t even do that because I’ve got to do that thing Mary asked me to do. If I do that for her she should help me with that problem I needed help with. Tomorrow, I need to do laundry, but I probably won’t make it to that because I have to go get our tickets for the ballgame. I really need to sit with Amy at the game because I should talk to her about the things I’ve seen her do that she shouldn’t be doing. I really shouldn’t be eating this cake now. I need to be writing a blog post.”
How do you feel after reading that paragraph? Good, excited, refreshed, bad, guilty?
- I should (do this or that).
- I should be doing (this or that).
- I ought to go see (so and so)
- I must do (this or that).
- If I do this for them then they should do that for me.
- If I treat them right then they should treat me right.
- I really shouldn’t be doing this.
- They shouldn’t be acting like that.
- I have to (or I”ve got to) go (do this or that)
- I need to go (do this or that).
- I need to go see (so and so).
Is it always bad to use all these words? Probably not, but an inaccurate thinker will motivate him/herself through guilt over and over again with these words and still feel bad all the time. He will also likely try to motivate others through guilt or put unrealistic expectations on others.
A person who motivates himself through guilt simply feels crummy all the time.
Someone who puts expectations on others (They should do this or that.) only sets him/herself up for failure because people often simply do not behave the way they should or the way we think they “should.”
So how does a person change this way of thinking to accurate healthy thinking?
1. An accurate thinker realizes others may not act the way he thinks they should. Therefore, he drops these expectations from his thinking completely and focuses on his own thinking and life and how to make it the best it can be regardless of what others think or do (or don’t think or do).
2. An accurate thinker sets a clearly defined path for his life, complete with a mission statement, priorities and goals and he acts accordingly. (Mike King has an excellent series on goal setting. This one specifically talks about setting and identifying goals.)
One of the most important lessons I am learning in our forum, Journey to Success, is the importance of clearly laying out exactly what I want out of life and how to achieve it. If you would like to get your life going on a clear path and have not yet joined us please accept this invitation to discuss the classic Think and Grow Rich by Napoleon Hill with us.
3. Once a person has set a clearly defined path for his life he uses language like “I will…..” or “I am going to…” or “I choose to….” (based on his predefined priorities) and the real difference - he does what he has set out is most important to do. This also frees him up to choose to say “No” to things that are not really important. An accurate thinker realizes that everything he does in life is a choice.
A life of guilt or a life of living…. The choice is ours.
I”ll be the first to admit that I have been guilty of this error. I worked on it, but I let myself slip back into it. I have set out my day saying things like, “I need to - or should (do this or that.)” and act according to that. Or I start to work on something and I think to myself “I need do (this or that). I get sidetracked easily. It’s not something I’m proud of. I resolve to work on this and to set out the life I want and to make choices accordingly.
Your turn:
Have you participated in this thinking error? How has it affected your life? Have you known of others who participated in the “should statements?” How did it affect their lives?
____________
To learn about the other thinking errors we have discussed follow these links and learn to Change Your Life - One Thought at a Time: Using names or labels and jumping to conclusions, filtering out the positive and polarized thinking, overgeneralization, mind reading and personalization, maximizing and minimizing, blaming, self pity, gloom and doom, controlling, emotional reasoning, being right, and Heaven’s Reward Fallacy.
____________
This post was helpful. How can I contribute something in return?
By purchasing from the coffee shop or bookstore. (It’s for a good cause.)







the shoulds, shouldn’ts, needs etc add alot of pressure. i see there use sneak into people’s self talk and self judgement.
in my opinion, it may be a result of poor stress and time management. we sometimes are running through life doing too many things and accepting too many things, that we have forgotten how to say no. many are living in reaction as opposed to proaction.
i have a monthly to do list. as i become aware of a task, i add it to the list. every night plan my tomorrow — not in a stringent, unforgiving way. i develop a loose plan for the day. i list the calls i want to make and select the items i want to action from my list.
as you say, i think i am working more with the ‘i am’ mentality instead of the ‘i should’ way of thinking. as i complete tasks i cross them off my list. periodically i recreate my list to clear out the ‘done’ items.
for me this works well.
without the list and the organization, i live more within the ‘i should’ world.
the one element that is uniquely me is that i prefer a manual list — i know there are many computerized tools i could use, but they just do not work for me. i prefer the quiet time and ceremony of making a list. i spend time with the items and this keeps me aware.
it works for me.
storm
storms last blog post..are you a donor?
Hi Jennifer. I catch this all the time in myself — “should” is nasty! I like how it changes the feeling though when I catch it and replace the should with will or want to. It lightens the load and is much more motivating.
Davinas last blog post..How Curious Moments Add Value
Hi Jennifer,
Great post, again. “Should” is a word I grew up with, and used on myself and others a lot, until I realised how much misery it was causing. So I agree with you. Now I say “I could avoid that third cup of coffee, but I choose to drink it” rather than “I should not be drinking this”. The first statement takes responsibility without assigning guilt and is thus a powerful statement, while the second doesn’t serve much purpose, really, except to make my feel ‘crummy’.
Daphnes last blog post..How Does Your Life Script Read?
Hi Jennifer,
I try pretty hard to avoid this one. I don’t like these words because I feel that they put up barriers when used toward other people, or when other people use them toward me. If I hear the word ‘need’ or ’should’ from someone - I instantly feel like I’m put in a defensive position. It feels this way because I don’t want to fail - and these words do set people up for failure if they are unable to do the thing that follows these words.
Guilt. That IS it. And guilt is not a good motivator for people. I’m much more motivated by desires, or the choices that I make. In choosing, you are actively saying you’re involved in this decision. And in choosing, you are taking away the position of guilt that comes from the “should’s” of the world.
Does this all mean I don’t use these words, or that I don’t make this thinking error? No. I’m guilty. I need to work on using these words less often…
See that last sentence - how easy it was to commit this thinking error right here in the comments, while I’m actively thinking about this one. A better sentence there would be -
“I’m choosing to work to limiting my use of the ’shoulds’ and the ‘needs’ from my vocabulary, so that I can offer up statements that don’t bring up other’s defense mechanisms.”
It’s easy to use these words, and not even realize it (as noted in the last couple of paragraphs above). That says to me that this all takes very active listening to ourselves when we speak.
This has been a great series Jennifer! Now, if I can just remember all of this. Is there a page where all the thinking errors are listed?
Lances last blog post..Are These My Skinny Jeans?
Storm, the should statements really do put a lot of unnecessary pressure on us, don’t they! Interesting how you brought up that it brings us to judging ourselves. Good point.
I think a lot of it is poor stress and time management. The gift to say No is a real gift. We simply forget it’s an option as we get in the go, go, go mindset. I wonder how often I could be more proactive instead of reactive? - more I know.
Thank you for sharing your tips on time management. Your system is similar to mine, but different as well. It sounds great. The key is for people to find what works for them and keeps them moving toward their goals.
I also prefer a manual list. It works best for me. Maybe not for others, but it does for me.
Davina, I just caught myself last night using the “should” after I finished this post. I changed it instantly to make it lighter. It made all the difference. I agree that “should” is a really nasty word. Out with it!
I think it’s a big reason for procrastination. You subconsciously fight against stuff you “should” do or “have to do” and it becomes a force. I always use “have to”, but I’m slowly starting to become aware when I use it and stop myself. It’s crazy how you post this and I just finished reading something similar in The 7 Habits of Highly Effective People.
Broderick Allens last blog post..Persistence
Hi Daphne. Thanks. Good for you for finally realizing the burdens of this word and for changing it. I can tell you are very wise. It is all about taking responsibility, isn’t it! Stopping the use of these phrases like “should” really forces a person to take responsibility. It’s pretty powerful! It sure is better than feeling “crummy.”
Hi Lance. These words do put up barriers, don’t they! It is like the “You” Rule that I wrote about on your blog. Often the word “you” precedes a “should” or “need” and that automatically puts people on the defense. I like how you pointed out that it sets people up for failure (or feeling like a failure) if they are unable to do these things. Great reason not to use it. We also set ourselves up for failure by using it toward ourselves.
You’re right Lance. Guilt is it and it is a terrible motivator. Making choices and doing what we enjoy gives us freedom and that just feels good. It boosts our self-esteem.
I’m sure most people do use these words - at least some. It’s something that most people, including myself, can work on. Just like I mentioned above, I caught myself using it right after writing this post!
I loved how you caught yourself and reworded it. Doesn’t that feel great! - to have the awareness of what we are doing to ourselves and actively change our words to take control of our thoughts and actions! See you’ve made improvements already! As you’ve pointed out, awareness and listening is key!
I’m glad that you’ve enjoyed this series, Lance. I know I sure have. I’ll be compiling a list of these thinking errors for you and everyone to have on hand as a reference in some form. Thanks for that great suggestion.
Hi Broderick. I bet you’re reading about the quadrants in the 7 Habits. That’s good material. What a great book! (Now, if I would just remember everything in it all the time!) It was really influential to me. The “should’s” do leave us fighting against ourselves. I like how you brought that up about procrastination. No wonder people procrastinate - they don’t really want to do it (whatever “it” is) because they have just put a guilt trip on themselves to do it. If I say to myself, “I should do that,” I don’t even want to do it now because I feel like I “have” to do it. Great point.
Hi Jennifer, great points here.
I absolute agree with your thought. We all have a choice that we must take, every second, every minute, every hour, every day and so on. We also must ready to accept all consequences from our choices.
But sometimes, people could not accept the consequences. They said I should take the another choice, and I think regret is a wrong attitude.
Thanks for sharing, Jennifer.
Arswinos last blog post..Sacrifice Play
Hi Jennifer
I too am a list maker. I love hand writing my list and crossing it out when I finish a task. I wouldn’t say I should, cause I choose what I want to do. So I shouldn’t have to do anything, it is just I want to do the things I do. Some time it is for the reason that I know it is in my best interest to do, sometime it is because I am passionate about a vision, and therefore, I want to do…
Which ever the case may be, I choose!
Thanks for a great post.
Giovanna Garcia
Imperfect Action is better than No Action
Giovanna Garcias last blog post..Finding your inner voice with Imperfect Action.
Like all these “errors” you’ve discussed, we’re never going to be perfect with all of them all the time. I think the key here, for me, has been an awareness. Just being aware means that I’m at least more likely to commit these errors less often, catch myself when I am making them, or realize that I have made them. And that’s all really good stuff. Even if I’m not perfect with these, just taking steps in the direction of minimizing these is huge.
Have a great weekend Jennifer!
Lances last blog post..Are These My Skinny Jeans?
Excellent, Jennifer. Yes, I stumble over those thinking errors quite often–and am sure that I will again.But then, to do other than accept this fact and be at peace with it would be indulging in another thinking error.
The truth may be recognized before the peace to live it is realized.–Strike a Chord of Silence
blessings and peace,
CG
CG Walterss last blog post..CelebraZine 23Jan09
[...] instead. If you feel that way, read this excellent post by Jennifer at Principles for Peace on why “should” is not a good word to use on yourself. “Don’t let your special character and values, the secret that you know and no one else [...]
Hi Arswino. It is all a choice, isn’t it. And we must be ready for all the consequences - good or bad. Hmmm…. You’ve got me thinking about the regret thing. I’m not sure I understand what you are saying about it, but I’m pretty sure that nobody wants to live their lives with regret. If we do not do something because people think we “should” not then we are likely to live a life of regret for not making our own choices. Hmmm…..
Hi Giovanna. Another list maker… There is just something about handwriting a list, isn’t there! I think the whole problem is that most people make lists of the things they “should” do and not the things that they really want to do or that are most important. I’ve been guilty. Making a list based on what you actually want to do and have deemed important based on good things like passion and vision is the direction to head in. Good for you for choosing! Glad you enjoyed the post.
Lance, we’re never going to be perfect. Great point!! I’m going to keep improving though. What is really cool is that the more I work on these the more that accurate thoughts become automatic for me. It’s still a journey, but I use the errors less and I’m going to keep working on them. Like you said, the key is awareness. If we are aware of the errors then when we use them we can then change them. And like you said again, that is HUGE!!!
Hi CG. We are human, aren’t we! We must accept that fact, huh? I think you’re referring to perfectionism - polarized thinking - with the other error. Very good CG and thanks for pointing that out. We must be forgiving of ourselves as we see and admit our mistakes, learn from them and then move on. That brings a lot of peace.
I love the way you called out and phrased accurate thinker.
I’m a fan of intellectual horsepower.
J.D. Meiers last blog post..Left Brainers and Right Brainers
Hi J.D. and welcome! (I think you may have been here before ?) Glad you enjoyed the way I called out the accurate thinker. It help us to see the opposite extreme (the right direction). Intellectual horsepower…. I like that phrase!
GREAT POST! I was a man of should long ago. I’ve transformed myself to replace should with MUST because it simply gets things done in less time.
AJ Kumars last blog post..What do Hitler and Obama Have in Common?
AJ, So “must” gets you moving? It puts urgency on things. Thanks for sharing. I like to use “will.” Keeps me responsible.
[...] personally have found that doing away with the “shoulds” is a huge stress preventative in my life - along with taking my “me” [...]