Change Your Life - One Thought at a Time - Part 3
happiness, inner peace, marital satisfaction, thinking errors August 28th, 2008Before we begin the discussion of overgeneralizing, I wanted to say:
A Word of Thanks:
I don’t know about you, but I sure have learned a lot from this thinking error series. Not only have I learned a lot from writing about the errors, but I have learned so much from you, my readers and commenters as you have helped to shed a different light on some of the errors.
As I was writing the last post, the more I wrote the more I realized that I engaged in the polarized thinking more than I thought I did. Coming up with examples was really helpful to me. And your comments caused me to think even further.
Thanks to Lance and Evelyn for their excellent discussion of filtering in their driving, to Tom about polarized thinking and decision making (that was an excellent point), to Jarrod for reminding us that good and bad are labels that hinder us from seeing things as they are (another excellent point), and to Cath for giving us the example of how the commenters on a post filtered out all the positive points on that post to point out the negative. A special thanks also goes out to all the other commenters in their encouraging words for this series and to all my readers who have written to me personally about the impact of my writing in their lives, and to those who choose to simply learn and apply these principles to their lives. I owe so much to each and every one of you. It is you, my readers, that give me inspiration to continue writing. Thank you all so much!
If you haven’t realized by now, often one thinking error is very closely connected to another one or leads to another one. You will likely notice that in your own thinking and in the thinking of others as you become a master of spotting the errors and a master of accurate thinking.
So let’s continue with some more thinking errors:
5. Overgeneralization: viewing events in terms of always or never.
Overgeneralization can either be directed toward yourself or someone else. You conclude that because something happened once it has or will always happen. Or because something didn’t happen once it has never happened and never will happen. In extreme overgeneralization, you conclude that because one bad thing happened to you that only bad things will ever happen to you.
Examples:
* One example used in the last post is also an example of overgeneralization: “I’ve never succeeded at anything.” As we pointed out last week this is simply not true. To prevent repeating myself click here to read that explanation there. This is also a good example of how thinking errors can be connected to each other.
* “You never help with the kids. ”
* “You’re always watching TV.”
* “You never help clean around here.”
* “I never can do anything right.” or “Can’t you ever do anything right?”
In his book, Feeling Good, Dr. David Burns says this about overgeneralization:
“The pain of rejection is generated almost entirely from overgeneralization. In its absense, a personal affront is temporarily disappointing, but cannot be seriously disturbing.
A shy young man mustered up his courage to ask a girl for a date. When she politely declined because of a previous engagement, he said to himself. ‘I’m never going to get a date. No girl would ever want a date with me. I’ll be lonely and miserable all my life.’ In his distorted cognitions, he concluded that because she turned him down once, she will always do so, and that since all women have 100 percent identical tastes, he would be endlessly and repeatedly rejected by any eligible woman on the face of the earth.”
Well, I planned on writing about another thinking error, but it looks like the length of this post is already about to the limit where I would like to keep it. I’ll save the other one for next time.
I’ll admit, I have at times participated in the whole rejection thing, and the never succeeded at anything error. I’ve told my husband he “never” does this or he “always” does that. It’s funny, nothing good ever came from any of it.
I would like to hear from you:
How has this thinking error effected your life? How have you seen it effect others’ lives. If you have changed from overgeneralization to accurate thinking, I would love to hear about your success stories as well. The floor is open for discussion…..
Is this blog helpful to you? Stretch yourself further by purchasing from the P4P Bookstore and subscribing to this blog. Don’t forget to tell a friend about us too.
Photo by: Gutter






August 28th, 2008 at 9:43 pm
Well, in addition to always and never, overgeneralization extends to create massive stereotypes. The whole -ism thinking, from racism to sexism to age-ism, are made up of overgeneralization. I guess there may be inherent laziness in our thinking — at least I notice in mine — to not want to look at each situation with fresh new eyes. Always bring in colored lenses, tinted by past.
For example, I’ve written about socioeconomic divide as perhaps just as tough of a barrier to overcome as racism. (http://ourbestversion.com/2008/06/is-the-socioeconomic-divide-the-hardest-wall-to-overcome/) People just don’t feel comfortable with others in a different socioeconomic class. It’s not really about the amount of money — it’s culture. I once worked in a gas delivery business. The truck drivers were often types of people I didn’t feel comfortable with. And it’s not about money — though they were blue-collar workers, some of them made a lot more money than I do. I am a bit ashamed to admit this, but I was full of assumptions about what they were like. I kept my distance and got out of there as fast as I could.
Another thing that’s tough to overcome is language. Being a non-native English speaker, I sometimes encountered people who underestimated me because my command on English was not great. But then, I find myself doing the same thing to others. I may jump to the conclusion that people with heavy accents are not very intelligent — and this coming from such a person himself! It’s possible that the person may have a PhD in his/her native country — but simply new to the language.
So — that’s a long way of saying, yes, I am aware of this problem, and yes, I’m trying to improve it.
ari
Ari Koinumas last blog post..Why You Can’t Do What You Love (Digest)
August 28th, 2008 at 10:05 pm
Hi Jenny - Thanks for the mention and the link.
I’m sure I overgeneralize sometimes. It’s easy to get into the habit of doing it isn’t it? Things like - “You’re always late”, or “you’re never organized” and it really is a bad thing isn’t it? I guess it’s really difficult for someone to break a bad habit, if you tell them they’re always doing it.
I’ll try to remember this next time that always word tries to slip out.
August 28th, 2008 at 10:11 pm
Jennifer - We work with our mental models. Our mental models are the stereotypical realities that we have created in our mind for anything and everything. The truth may be far from these mental models yet we believe them because we are misdirected by our own error of judgment.
Shilpan
Shilpan | successsoul.coms last blog post..10 Simple Habits to Help You Look Younger and Live Longer
August 29th, 2008 at 8:34 am
Something I think is understated is that we also overgeneralise what we think we know about people.
The idea that ‘first impressions count’ is based purely on this and this is unfortunate.
You can never really know someone, even from one day to the next, people could have changed.
Yet we assume we always know exactly who our friends are.
Tomorrow you should look at the people you see everyday as if you has just met them. Then you might find something new about them.
August 29th, 2008 at 11:25 am
Ari, thank you for your thoughtful words. It’s interesting that you brought up the -ism thinking - people of a certain race, nationality, etc. are “always” a certain way. I’ve made a reference to that thinking in several of the other thinking errors (labeling, polarized thinking). That makes me think - that whole attitude/mindset is so FULL of thinking errors.
The socioeconomic thing is a good point. I know I have felt uncomfortable around people of different classes and made judgments on them (they are “always” this way). It is a great person indeed who can look at anyone from any situation just for who they are. I also think though that we have certain instincts for a reason. Maybe you sensed trouble with the other truck drivers and knew that you needed to protect yourself by getting out of there. I don’t know…
It is very interesting indeed how we overgeneralize in regards to language - I have found myself doing that (I’m ashamed to admit). Interesting… Your English is so good in your writing I would have never guessed you weren’t a native English speaker! You certainly sound intelligent to me so I know I would have not made any judgment from your writing.
Cath, your welcome for the link. Yes, overgeneralization is an easy habit to get into and a hard one to break, but not impossible. It just takes some effort. I love the point you brought out about how it’s difficult for someone to break a bad habit if your telling them they are always doing it. In fact, we can create habits in ourselves and in other people just by using the words always and never.
Shilpan, thanks for bringing that up about mental models. We tell ourselves what we want to believe and do our thinking and living from that. Indeed we do lie to ourselves over and over again.
Jarrod, good point about first impressions (and all other impressions). If someone has had a bad day when we meet them, we might say to ourselves, “Wow, Isn’t she a grouchy person - ie.- isn’t she “always” grouchy.” I love your last sentence!
It reminds me of this quote I came across recently: “To love someone is to see them as God intended them to be.” I think that is so powerful! That’s one thing I appreciated about my friend Ron. He trained himself to do that.
August 29th, 2008 at 12:10 pm
Jennifer, this really has been an eye-opening series you’ve given us. Onto todays errors: over generalization. I’m guilty. I’m getting better, but it still happens. For example: at a soccer game I was coaching maybe a year ago (9 year olds) I started complaining to my wife that why do all the referees we have for our games make bad calls. See - over generalization. Because in this case, it was really just one game, and maybe one single call from an earlier game. So, really, most of the season was refereed very well. But I wasn’t seeing it at that moment. I made a generalization based upon one game. Since then, and after having come to this realization, I look at it completely different. We are all prone to errors. And what I’m seeing and what they’re seeing might be different just because of the angle. I might be biased toward my team. Etc. Now, I really work to understand it from their viewpoint, and that has really helped me not to over generalize.
August 29th, 2008 at 12:41 pm
Lance, that was an excellent example. I played softball earlier this summer and most of the players on our team were making the same kind of comments about our referees and our season. I didn’t overgeneralize about it as much as they did, but I admit I still participated.
I like your point about giving people the benefit of the doubt. People do see things differently - everyone does. No one has the same genes or the same experiences. All this plays a part in how we see things. I think it is so important to remember that.
August 29th, 2008 at 3:54 pm
As a life and career coach sometimes I feel like I spend a good part of my coaching sessions calling clients on their self over-generalizations. This is a really dangerous habit because we become unaware over time that we are even doing it. Often the over-generalization becomes a permanent label that greatly affects our confidence.
One prejudice I still have that I’m sure is an over- generalization is that old male drivers with hats driving Buicks are slow and confused.
I also used to label myself as unable to learn technology. A fellow coach pointed that one out to me and I stopped it. We need to speak up more for one another. I appreciate the link.
August 29th, 2008 at 3:57 pm
Hey Jen, you may want to deactivate and reactivate your comment luv plug-in. It doesn’t seem to be working. Sorry to tell you here. I couldn’t find your contact page.
Tom Volkar / Delightful Works last blog post..How to Honor Your Commitments
August 29th, 2008 at 4:56 pm
Tom, I can see how that would be a huge area in which you would have to help clients. Overgeneralizing is so detrimental to us and no we don’t even realize we are doing it. I would say that is a big task for you as you help people work through that.
I laughed so hard when I read your prejudice problem. I would have to admit to that one too. I think that was very wise of Buick to start making some sporty looking cars.
Thanks for letting me know about the comment luv. It seems it was working on some of the other comments. I’ll go check it out. You can always contact me through the About page any time. I have installed the contact plug-in yet. Sorry for the inconvenience.
August 29th, 2008 at 5:00 pm
Tom, I just deactivated and reactivated comment luv. Hopefully that will take care of everything. Let me know if you have any more trouble.
August 29th, 2008 at 7:28 pm
Love your advice on overgeneralization. Add to that the power of positive thinking…never give up…tomorrow’s another day…and you have the basis of what is needed to keep going. Great post.
peace,
mike
livelife365
Mike Fosters last blog post..Do You Believe?
August 29th, 2008 at 8:34 pm
Thank you so much for the link.
I noticed that many of us falling into the trap of over generalization. Without naming anyone in particular, I would like to admit that I’ve been very guilty of this “thinking error” in the past.
Needless to say, over generalizing has not been helpful because it brings out the victim mentality. It also feeds on low self esteem. At the same time, whatever “truths” that over generalization thrive on is never a fact but the making of a myopic mind.
August 30th, 2008 at 3:33 am
Hi Jennifer,
When I hear someone generalizing, saying “I’ll never…..”, I either want to tell they, “you’re right”, or warn them how their words are shaping their future.
Barbara Swaffords last blog post..Plugins, Questions and Open Mic
August 30th, 2008 at 3:09 pm
Jennifer, I am so excited to find your blog. I subscribe to Ari’s and have been following your discussion with him for a few days now. Being on the road, I did not have time to really get into your mind until today… all I can say is wow! I am thankful, so thankful to be discovering minds like mine. I am really new to blogging. I just sat down one day and decided to write a book, which led me to begin “blogging my mind.” As a result, I have found comfort and inspiration by reading the thoughts of brilliant people like yourself. Let me encourage you to keep writing and should you publish any type of book, please let me know where I can buy a copy
If you get time, check out my mind and give me your honset feedback. Here is a sample poem that I feel is related to this post of yours. Peace — jb —
http://jeffbakertalks.blogspot.com/2008/08/can-you-relate-to-this.html
Jeff Bakers last blog post..Resubmission and revised version of the original - Part 2
August 31st, 2008 at 8:29 am
Jennifer;
First I wanted to know if it would be possible to switch your RSS feed from partial to full feeds? Just a preference - I like reading RSS feeds without having to click through to the blog right away. Thoughts?
Anyway, good point about overgeneralization. We all tend to make them from time to time. you’re right. It doesn’t do any good to overgeneralize like that. Good point.
The way we cut down on that is by becomeing aware. It’s used as an excuse to stop ourselves from stepping up to the plate - that’s what it seems to be used for. It’s a blockage we put on ourselves.
This one made me think - and that’s always good! Making your readers think, ponder, etc.
Stephen Hopsons last blog post..End of the Week Gratitude Theme #43
August 31st, 2008 at 9:46 am
Jennifer, you make an excellent point with this post!
I think over-generalization also takes us out of the present moment - instead of simply being with what is right now, we immediately jump into “always” and “never” which takes away from the fullness of our present experience.
Blessings,
Andrea
Andrea Hess|Empowered Souls last blog post..Creating Our Vibrational State
August 31st, 2008 at 3:29 pm
Mike, good point! We have to replace the overgeneralization with the right things (positive thoughts) or we will just keep gong back to that way of thinking.
Evelyn, I too have engaged in this thinking. I’m working more and more to stop it. I was going to comment back on your last paragraph, but you summed it all up VERY well!
Barbara, I love your point about how our words shape our (or others’) future. Self fulfilling prophesy is another way to say that.
August 31st, 2008 at 4:00 pm
Jeff, let me extend a warm welcome to you!! I’m glad you found my blog also. I do plan on publishing a book. I’ll let you know when I do. Thanks for reminding me to stay focused on doing just that. I’d love to read yours as well.
That is a great poem that goes well with this post. Thanks for sharing it.
Stephen, thanks for your feedback. I just sent you an email about the RSS feed.
Awareness… Ahh, that’s the key. That’s what I’m hoping to help people do here - become aware of their overgeneralizations.
Love your point about overgeneralization being an excuse not to step up to the plate. I think you are right. It’s an easy way out for us. Glad I could make you think. Maybe you can use this in your speaking engagements.
Andrea, I think you are right. It does take us away from the present moment. Instead, we could simply look at what is happening in the present and deal with the one particular issue at hand - that keeps things from being blown out of proportion.
Great discussion everyone!!!
September 2nd, 2008 at 11:54 pm
very good
September 3rd, 2008 at 12:07 pm
Sameer, Welcome! So glad you enjoyed it.
September 4th, 2008 at 6:46 pm
[...] Overgeneralization [...]
November 4th, 2008 at 5:35 pm
[...] posts: Labeling and Jumping to Conclusions, Filtering out the Positive and Polarized Thinking, Over Generalization, Mind Reading and Personalization, and Maximizing and [...]
November 19th, 2008 at 6:06 pm
[...] names or labels and jumping to conclusions, filtering out the positive and polarized thinking, overgeneralization, mind reading and personalization, maximizing and minimizing, blaming, self pity, gloom and [...]